
Below is a selection of some of the prominent cases Simon has worked on. The list is curated to show the breadth and depth of Simon’s skills and experience.
Set out below are brief summaries of selected cases in which I acted as counsel. These cases demonstrate the breadth and depth of my litigation experience. Not included are numerous cases that were settled through negotiation, mediation or judicial settlement conference.
Acted for mortgagees applying for possession of mortgaged land. Successfully opposed application for interim injunction attempting to stop mortgagee sale.
Acting for defendant mortgagees defending a claim in the High Court for breach of mortgagee’s duties in relation to a mortgagee sale. Applied for defendant’s summary judgment and summary judgment on counterclaim. Partially successful and obtained leave to appeal and awaiting a hearing date from the Court of Appeal .
Acted for defendant mortgagees defending a claim in the High Court for breach of mortgagee’s duties. Applied for and obtained the defendant’s summary judgment.
Acted for Sky Media Limited defending District Court claim in defamation relating to posts on my clients social media website. The five day trial involved important issues in the law of defamation including what is required for a website host to be a publisher and the relationship between defamation and the Harmful Digital Communications Act 2015.
Acted for the respondents successfully opposing an application to remove a caveat. The case involved whether the respondents had an arguable case for specific performance of a contract or for a resulting or constructive trust
Acted for the defendants in a two week trial in the High Court and on a two day appeal to the Court of Appeal. The case involved complex disputed issues of fact and law relating to a failed joint venture between the parties and required Chinese interpreters.
Acted for the plaintiff claiming defamation in a multi-day trial in the Gisborne District Court. The case involved highly contested issues of fact and law. Acted on appeal to the High Court.
Acted for the plaintiffs in a ten day High Court trial and one day hearing in the Court of Appeal. The case involved complex disputed issues of fact and law regarding allegations of misrepresentation and breach of the Fair Trading Act 1986 and required Chinese interpreters.
Acted for the applicant claiming refugee status on appeal and judicial review from the decision of Immigration and Protection Tribunal. Applied successfully to the Court of Appeal for leave to appeal and seek judicial review (leave having been refused by the High Court) and then successfully appealed and obtained judicial review in the High Court. The case involved important issues of what natural justice requires in relation to granting adjournments to allow a party to obtain legal representation.
Acted for the applicant claiming refugee status on appeal and judicial review from the decision of Immigration and Protection Tribunal. Applied successfully to the Court of Appeal for leave to appeal and seek judicial review (leave having been refused by the High Court) and then successfully appealed and obtained judicial review in the High Court. This is a very important case in that it clarified and changed the approach that the IPT must take in deciding refugee status claims.
Acted for the plaintiff lessee in a five day trial in the District Court for breach of a commercial lease and wrongful re-entry. The case involved highly contested issues of fact and law.
Acted for the claimant, instructed by the Director of Human Rights Proceedings, on a five day trial in the Human Rights Review Tribunal, successfully claiming that the Police discriminated against Mr King on the grounds of his disability in relation to the way he was treated in Police cells with claustrophobia.
Acted for the Director on behalf of three women on a nine day trial in the Human Rights Review Tribunal successfully claiming that Netsafe interfered with the aggrieved individuals’ privacy by failing to provide them with their personal information. The case is significant in that it deals with the relationship between the Privacy Act 1993 and the Harmful Digital Communications Act 2015.
Acted for the plaintiff in a claim for provision from her father’s will under the Family Protection Act 1955. In addition to the substantive claim, the case involved difficult issues regarding enforcement of the judgment including sale orders, orders for arrest of the debtor and enforcement in Australia.
Acted for the refugee appellant applying for leave to appeal. Although the application did not succeed, the Court of Appeal’s findings created an important precedent for future cases.
Acted for a solicitor defending professional misconduct charges in the Lawyers and Conveyancers Disciplinary Tribunal and opposing an appeal to the High Court.
Acted for a real estate agent in the Real Estate Agents Disciplinary Tribunal and opposing and appeal to the High Court. The case involved a review of a decision by the Registrar of the REA not to grant him a new licence. It is important in discussing the requirement of the Registrar to focus on future risk rather than past behaviour when considering such applications.
Acted for a plaintiff bringing a claim for defamation in the District Court. The claim was struck out in the District Court on the basis of absolute privilege but was reinstated by the High Court on appeal. Appeals to the Court of Appeal and Supreme Court were dismissed. The judgments are important in clarifying when the defence of absolute privilege applies in defamation.
Acted for the Director of Human Rights Proceedings on behalf of a claimant alleging discrimination on the grounds of pregnancy. The respondent applied for judicial review claiming that the HRRT did not have jurisdiction because the Parental Leave and Employment Protection Act 1987 (PLEPA) gave the Employment Court exclusive jurisdiction. Successfully opposed the judicial review in the High Court and Court of Appeal. Important case clarifying the relationship between the Human Rights Act 1993, the Employment Relations Act 2000 and the PLEPA.
Acted for a plaintiff applying successfully for judicial review of a decision by the Minister of Immigration declining her application for a partnership residence visa. Important case in clarifying that even if the legislation allows the Minister to make a decision without giving reasons, the decision can still be judicially reviewed.
Acted for Don Ha appealing a decision of the Real Estate Agent’s Disciplinary Tribunal to the High Court.
Acted for a property owner successfully applying for summary possession of land from his sister who had lived in the property for many years. The court held no tenable defence despite the defendant’s claims of promises made to her and money spent on the property.
Acted for the Director in a successful claim for breach of the Privacy Act 1993 by Cameron Slater and Whaleoil. The claim required a multi- day trial and related to posts on the Whaleoil site about Matthew Blomfield.
Acted for a plaintiff purchaser who had cancelled a sale and purchase agreement due to non-compliance with a special condition. Obtained summary judgment confirming valid cancellation because the special condition could not be waived by defendant. Important case of contract interpretation.
Acted for property owners successfully resisting an application that a caveat not lapse in the High Court, Court of Appeal and Supreme Court. The applicant liquidators alleged that my clients were liable in knowing receipt of money used to purchase the property and co it was held on constructive trust. This was rejected by the courts. This is an important case in clarifying the law of knowing receipt and is the subject of academic commentary in articles and text books, e.g [2017] NZLJ 292.
Acted for the claimant, instructed by the Director of Human Rights Proceedings, alleging racial harassment by his employer in breach of the Human Rights Act 1993. Following a three day trial of disputed facts, the HRRT found in favour of the plaintiff. The case is significant as the first case in New Zealand dealing with racial harassment.
Acted for a defendant who had signed a sale and purchase agreement as agent for the purchaser. Obtained defendant’s summary judgment against the vendor on basis that client was only an agent and not liable under the agreement. Important case in the law of agency.
Acted for a property owner successfully opposing an application for an interim injunction by a sub-purchaser seeking to prevent sale of the property. The case involved important and difficult issues regarding equitable interests of sub purchasers and the effect on sub-purchasers of cancellation of the agreement between owner and head purchaser.
Acted for a High School student with autism spectrum disorder who had been expelled from school. Successfully sought judicial review setting aside the suspension and expulsion decisions. Very important precedent in relation to the duties of school principals and Boards of Trustees to investigate and properly consider the impact of a disability on a student’s behaviour before making a suspension or expulsion decision.
Acted for the applicant seeking judicial review of the Commissioner’s refusal to accept settlement proposals in relation to tax liability.
Acted for respondent taxpayer opposing application to transfer its challenge to tax assessments from the TRA to the High Court.
Acted for the Director of Human Rights Proceedings successfully opposing an application for judicial review of the HRRT. The Director had obtained an interim order in the HRRT preventing SST from publishing details of a criminal record on its website. The SST applied for judicial review to the High Court and then appealed to the Court of Appeal. The case discusses and clarifies the jurisdiction of the HRRT.
Acted for a judgment debtor on an application to set aside a bankruptcy notice following protracted relationship property proceedings.
Acted for a defendant cladding assembler (Rudnev Door Systems) in a High Court leaky building claim. Obtained defendant’s summary judgment removing it from the proceedings on the basis that no arguable case based on the evidence and any amendment to the claim would be time barred by the Limitation Acts.
Acted for the respondent taxpayer opposing the transfer of its challenge from the TRA to the High Court
Acted for the applicant seeking an annulment of his bankruptcy adjudication under s 309(1)(a) of the Insolvency Act 2006. This was an important case in clarifying that an existing annulment under s 309(1)(b) did not prevent an applicant from applying for an annulment from the date of adjudication under s 309(1)(b). This was important for the client as it gave him a defence to criminal charges of carrying on business while bankrupt.
Acted for the Director to obtain an interim injunction requiring the SST to remove information from their website that infringed the Privacy Act,
Acted for the receivers of a property developer seeking to enforce a sale and purchase agreement in a five day High Court trial and on an appeal to the Court of appeal. The case involved difficult issues of contractual interpretation and misrepresentation under the Contractual Remedies Act 1979, Contract Mistakes Act 1977 and Fair Trading Act 1993.
Acted for the plaintiff real estate agency seeking to recover commissions. Successfully resisted strike out application and application by defendant for leave to appeal to the Court of Appeal.
Acted for applicant companies successfully applying for judicial review of a decision of the Commissioner of Inland Revenue to refuse to accept late objections to GST assessments.
Acted for the appellant in a 6 day hearing appealing against the decision of the TRA dismissing Mr Russell’s challenges to numerous tax assessments.
Acted for a defendant trustee defending claims of breach of trustee’s duties over a five day trial.
Acted for a High School student successfully applying for judicial review of suspension and expulsion decisions by the school principal and Board of Trustees. The case involved important issues of what natural justice requires in relation to school discipline decisions.
Acted for the plaintiff bringing claims under s 27 of the Commerce Act 1986 alleging anti-competitive agreements between the defendants.
Acted for the defendant who faced prosecution by the Commerce Commission of hundreds of charges of breaches of s 13 of the Fair Trading Act 1986 in a three week summary trial in the North Shore District Court. Many of the charges were dismissed with 31 convictions.
Acted for the plaintiff seeking specific performance of an agreement in relation to shares in a company. This case concerned the principles for appointing a receiver over the company’s assets pending trial and my client succeeded in continuing the appointment.
Acted for a high School student who had been expelled from school to bring judicial review of the suspension and expulsion decisions. The school appealed to the Court of Appeal where the High Court judgment was upheld. This was a very significant case in helping to clarify the approach schools should take to suspension and expulsion decisions. It changed the Ministry of Education guidance to schools.
Acted for the defendant who faced multiple charges of breaching s 17 of the Inland Revenue Department Act 1974 in the Manukau District Court. Applied successfully to have the charges dismissed.
Acted for an architect defendant in a weathertightness claim seeking judicial review of the WHRS for failing to dismiss the claim against the architect as time barred. Succeeded in persuading the High Court judge that another High Court decision was wrong.
Acted for a group of solicitor’s nominee company investors defending a claim that their mortgages over land should be declared invalid. Very important case regarding indefeasibility of title, fraud and agency law. Subject of academic commentary including P Watts, Imputed Knowledge in Agency Law-Knowledge Aquired Outside Mandate [2005] NZ Law Rev 607. Six day High Court trial, two day Court of Appeal hearing, leave application to Supreme Court.
Acted for purchasers of a business successfully applying for an interim injunction to restrain the vendors from acting as if the agreement was cancelled. The case involved the relationship between two contracts and where one varied the other.
Acted for a real estate agent in a claim in the Employment Court regarding whether he was an employee or an independent contractor. This was an important test case.
Acted for the respondent successfully opposing an application for special leave to appeal to the Privy Council in a case involving passing off. Appeared in the Privy Council before a panel led by Lord Hoffman.
Acted for the applicant successfully applying for leave to bring a derivative action on behalf of a company against the company’s director for breach of fiduciary duties.
Acted as junior defence counsel for David Phillips defending a prosecution by the Serious Fraud Office of hundreds of fraud charges. The case was a 3 month jury trial before Salmon J and jury in High Court, Auckland.
Acted as junior counsel for the plaintiffs in a claim for breach of fiduciary duty and breach of confidentiality against multiple defendants relating to the purchase and development of Matakana Island. Appeared on a three week trial in the High Court.